Frequently Asked Questions

Customized Designs

We love to work with our customers to create colors and designs that match a specific event. Some of examples of what our customers ask:

  • Creating company Logos for conventions, training seminars and thank-you gifts
  • Designing specialty shapes for product launches and store openings
  • Placing pictures on cookies for award ceremonies and on invitations for events
  • Adding names to cookies for weddings or party name cards

To start the discussions, please email or fax us a picture of what you are looking for.

Back to top


O'My Goodness cookies are made from only the finest ingredients, the same ingredients that you'd use if you were to bake them yourself. You can review the ingrediants   After being individually cut and baked, each cookie first has a base coat of royal icing applied, and then is hand decorated.   In total, it takes us three days to complete each masterpiece.

Cookie: unbleached flour, butter[milk], sugar, eggs, vanilla

Icing: powdered sugar, meringue powder [potato starch, cream of tartar, baking soda, xanthan gum, salt, lactic acid, egg albumen], water and corn syrup, contains 2% or less of the following: artificial color yellow #5, titanium dioxide yellow #6, red #3, red #40, blue #1, glycerin, sorbitol modified food starch, preservative [sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate], vegetable gum, citric acid

Contains milk, eggs, wheat flour

For those with Peanut allergies, we operate in a Peanut-Free environment

Back to top

Trans fats

0, none, nill. Who would of thought that cooking with nothing but butter would be a healthly thing. Turns out that milk has no trans fats.

Back to top

Good Manufacturing Process

OMG is annually certified by AIB.

Back to top

International Orders

At the current time, we only ship within the United States of America and Canada

Back to top

O'My Goodness is certified Kosher

We are certified by the Chicago Rabinical Council. Click here to see our current certification


The following are the nutrition facts for our regular butter cookie:

Serving Size

1 Cookie (57 g, 2 oz)
Servings Per Container:  1

Nutrition Amount Per Serving:
Trans fats 0 g
Calories 240
Calories from Fat 90
% Daily Value *
Total Fat   10 g


    Saturated Fat 6 g


Cholesterol 35 mg


Sodium   15 mg


Total Carbohydrate 35 g


    Dietary Fiber less than 1 g


    Sugars 20 g  
Protein 3 g  
Vitamin A 8%
Vitamin C 0%
Calcium 0%
Iron 6%

*Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet.  Your daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.

      Calories     2,000     2,500
Total Fat Less than 65 g 25 g
   Sat Fat Less than 20 g 25 g
Cholesterol Less than 300 mg 300 mg
Sodium  Less than 2,400 mg 2,400 mg
Total Carbohydrate  300 mg 375 mg
    Dietary Fiber 25 mg 30 mg
Calories per gram
Fat  9 Carbohydrate 4 Protein 4

Back to top


Our cookies are package three different ways:

  • Cookies purchased individually are packaged in clear bags, heat sealed, and carefully tied with colorful tulle. Cookies are then protected with bubble wrap before being placed in the shipping box
  • Gift Boxes contain cookies that also individually packaged as described above, then protected with bubble before being placed into the gift box. Gift boxes are then placed into a shipping box
  • Our cookie tins have padding between each layer of cookies. The tin is then placed into the shipping box
Orange cookie in clear bag tied with orange tulle
Back to top

Shelf Life

Our cookies have a shelf-life of six months, even though we use no preservatives. We've even received calls from customers whom have eaten our cookies after a year or more and they still thought the cookies tasted great! However, we recommend that you don't wait quite that long before enjoying their buttery goodness.

Back to top


O'My Goodness ships all orders out of it's Lake Bluff, Illinois, bakery. We normally ship out Postal Mail to Alaska, Hawaii and Canada and Federal Express Ground to all other location in US. We can expedite shipments upon request.

Back to top